· Thesis: In accordance with Dershowitz, torture should be acceptable when it is absolutely needed, however those inflicting the torture needs to be held accountable for their actions by the government. According to Dershowitz, the ticking time bomb terrorist should be tortured based on the overwhelming effects that can be prevented when dealing with a An Argument on Torture. Torture. Words: (5 pages) Dictionary. com defines torture as “the act of inflicting excruciating pain, as punishment or revenge, as a means of getting a confession or information, or for sheer cruelty. ” A second definition at dictionary. com states torture as “extreme anguish of body or mind; blogger.comted Reading Time: 3 mins · Read Full Paper. Torture has been a tool of coercion for nearly all of human history, whether to instill fear in a population or force people to convert, but almost all contemporary attempts to justify the use of torture revolve around torture as a means of extracting information from a victim. Used in this context, torture has a number of prominent
Free Torture Essay Examples and Topic Ideas on GraduateWay
One of the central pillars of the court process in the common law system of justice is built on the bedrock assumption that coercive interrogation works. All people in common law countries must give evidence in court when subpoenaed to do so. This is even when they have no connection to the case, apart from having to be a witness to a relevant event. Many people have no desire to get involved in any form of litigation. It is often stressful and nearly always time consuming.
Sometimes it puts them at risk of reprisal by a party to the proceeding. Despite this, they are always forced to give evidence under threat of imprisonment if they do not provide relevant information.
It is assumed that this coerced evidence is truthful Barnet et al. Therefore, the argument that torture never works essay on torture unsupportable, essay on torture. Rather, the most accurate assessment of the efficacy of torture as an information-gathering device is that it will sometimes fail, while, on other occasions, it will succeed. However, torture should not be mistreatment for punitive reasons and the suspect should have the relevant information.
It transpires that even essay on torture most effective torture techniques only elicit the relevant information in a small number of cases. For the torture to be justified, it would mean that the plus side of the scales would need to be heavier than the negative side, essay on torture.
In the case where thousands of lives were at stake, even 20 percent likelihood that torture would be effective would justify its use. Ultimately, one cannot be guaranteed that torture will work in any given instance, but one can essay on torture virtually certain that doing nothing will fail when faced with an imminent catastrophe.
According to Hickmanhe believed that torture is more efficient than other forms of punishments in obtaining the relevant information and enhancing national security. The utilitarian-expediency argument is that one has to be kept in prison for a long time in order to achieve the desired punitive and deterrent goals of the state. However, essay on torture torture can achieve these goals in a shorter period, torture is justified regardless of the mental pain of time and the long-term effects associated with being subjected to torture.
Consequently, it is not that faith and values frames do not also apply; it is that torture is inseparable from the national security of the Americans. It is just a fundamental truth that Americans, and American policymakers, perceive torture in this context. It is not disputing the enormity of the moral implications of torture; rather it is that framing opposition to torture in terms of moral or religious imperatives is vital.
However, it does not remove torture from the national security context. In an attempt to combat these real and supposed threats, state may adopt a policy of torture.
In this case, essay on torture, the vital goals of torture are to maintain the authority of those in power by systematically destroying those who are a threat to them and to intimidate all others into conformity.
In order to legitimize the use of state torture, the authorities frequently point to a history of violence against the state, real or imagined. This violence takes the form of insurgency, guerilla operations, essay on torture, or terrorist attacks.
As part of the threat assessment approach, people can be subjected to torture, not because essay on torture criminal acts that they have performed or are planning to perpetrate. However, as they hold political or religious beliefs that are deemed dangerous to the state, they cannot deliver the stated goals essay on torture the stipulated essay on torture framework Rejali In addition, any possible threat to the state enables the authority to create a purpose and a justification for the implementation of a torture policy.
The state sanitizes torture essay on torture the eyes of the public. Torture is necessary in protecting the society from internal and external threats. The state determines the legitimate targets of torture by successfully applying negative labels to certain groups or individuals. Torture, therefore, must be seen as an expression of state power and a method of constituting and expressing the domination of the state over its subjects, essay on torture.
For instance, it has been argued that the detainees from the War essay on torture Terror held by the Americans at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba possess little valuable, actionable intelligence. Given this, it appears that deterrence and control are the primary motivations behind continued use of torture.
In effect, the use of torture serves to transform an individual into the enemy. This transformation is perhaps the most vital aspect for torture. Another central economic factor related to the utility of state torture is the distribution of wealth within the country.
Without a minimum level of wealth, redistribution through taxation or other means, vastly unequal lifestyles and opportunities of wealth is based on race or ethnicity. In this circumstance, the political or ruling elite are much more susceptible to violent attacks from the terrorists. Given this, essay on torture, the regime may use state torture and other terror tactics in order to ensure the status quo and control any disenfranchised groups Hickman However, in advanced capitalist societies, the distribution of wealth helps to maintain a standard of living among most citizens, which diminishes the potential for internal violent conflict.
In addition to economic factors, the political organization of the state plays a crucial role in the utility of state torture. In addition, political systems face fewer political, social, essay on torture, or economic constraints to the use of torture. Moreover, agrarian and industrial nations have traditionally experienced a significant degree of political instability with military governments that have benefited from policies of torture.
Critical Thinking, Reading, and Writing: A Brief Guide to Argument. Essay on torture, Gill. Leading Change in Multiple Contexts: Concepts and Practices in Organizational, Community, Political, Social, and Global Change Settings. London: SAGE, Rejali, Darius. Torture and Democracy. New York City: Princeton University Press, Need a custom Essay sample written from scratch by professional specifically for you? certified writers online, essay on torture.
We use cookies to give you the best experience possible. If you continue, we will assume that you agree to our Cookies Policy. Learn More. We will write a custom Essay on Torture specifically for you! Not sure if you can write a paper on Torture by yourself?
This essay on Torture was written and submitted by your fellow student. You are free to use it for research and reference purposes in order to write your own paper; however, you must cite it accordingly. Removal Request. If you are the copyright owner essay on torture this paper and no longer wish to have your work published on IvyPanda. Strategic Planning and Performance Measurement for Wounded Warrior Project Differences and Similarities between Hamas and Hezbollah.
GET WRITING HELP. Cite This paper. Select a referencing style:. Copy to Clipboard Copied! APA-6 MLA-8 Chicago N-B Chicago A-D Harvard. Reference IvyPanda. Work Cited "Torture. Bibliography IvyPanda. References IvyPanda. More related papers. Check the price of your paper. If you continue, essay on torture, we will assume that you agree to our Cookies Policy OK.
Let's Get Haunted! Episode 87: The Witches, Ghosts, and Werewolves of Moosham Castle
, time: 1:36:27Torture Essay - Examples & Papers
Essay On Torture. Torture is inflicting pain on someone to get them to say or do blogger.come is one of the crimes that humans have committed for many centuries. Many rulers used torture to gain insight into their enemies movements and plans and used torture to gain insight on their subjects actions An Argument on Torture. Torture. Words: (5 pages) Dictionary. com defines torture as “the act of inflicting excruciating pain, as punishment or revenge, as a means of getting a confession or information, or for sheer cruelty. ” A second definition at dictionary. com states torture as “extreme anguish of body or mind; blogger.comted Reading Time: 3 mins · Read Full Paper. Torture has been a tool of coercion for nearly all of human history, whether to instill fear in a population or force people to convert, but almost all contemporary attempts to justify the use of torture revolve around torture as a means of extracting information from a victim. Used in this context, torture has a number of prominent
No comments:
Post a Comment